Deflect a double whammy

Feb. 13, 2008
Consider new options for tackling economic and environmental concerns.

Some in the chemical industry probably dismiss talk about the potential widespread use of renewable resources as feedstocks as wishful thinking. Cynics may write the hoopla off as a ploy by the agricultural lobby or other vested interests to wrangle more money out of the government. Skeptics may argue that biofeedstocks may make sense in very specific, limited circumstances but won’t provide a practical platform for many chemicals.

I strongly disagree with the naysayers. As we’ve regularly reported (see, for instance,, significant progress in commercializing renewable-resource-based routes is occurring. Major players like Dow and Dupont already have processes relying on such feedstocks.

The rising prices of crude oil and natural gas certainly are boosting the relative economics of using biofeedstocks — and thus companies’ interest. After all, no chemical producer can afford to ignore prospective bottom-line benefits.

Some firms also value the sustainability of such feedstocks and their potential for cutting harmful emissions, as I’ve already noted (

So, it’s no surprise that acceptance of biofeedstocks is accelerating. But the question remains about just how extensive a role they can play. Analyses done at the University of Utrecht in Holland provide some insights. Barbara G. Hermann of the school’s Department of Science, Technology and Society looked at 15 chemicals that potentially could be made via fermentation — chosen with the help of a panel of experts from companies such as BP, DSM, Dupont and Shell — and that could support annual production of at least 200,000 metric tons in Western Europe.

She developed a generic approach for evaluating the chemicals, which range from caprolactam to ethylene to succinic acid, on a common basis, comparing fermentation-based and conventional production (see p. TK). For the bio-based routes, she did analyses for current and future technology (which she assumed would involve continuous fermentation and achieve yields of 90 mol.% of their theoretical maximum, thanks to better genetically engineered microorganisms).

Her first study, published last year in Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology, focused solely on economics. She developed profited production costs (which are akin to market prices). These included operating expenses as well as capital charges reflecting the investment required for a new 100,000-m.t./yr. plant in Western Europe; sensitivity analyses addressed variations in the prices of sugar and oil, as well as plant size. With current prices, bio-based routes using today’s technology provide better economics for many of these bulk chemicals, she concludes. As a feedstock, sugar cane fares best, followed by lignocellulosics and then corn starch.

Hermann then evaluated the potential savings in non-renewable-energy use and greenhouse gas emissions for the same 15 chemicals over their entire life cycle, and has just reported her findings in Environmental Science & Technology. Almost all bio-based routes using current technology offer clear benefits on both counts and future technology may allow cuts in greenhouse gas emissions to exceed 100% in some cases, when energy credits are factored in, she notes.

So, biofeedstocks may offer chemical makers broad opportunities to address both economic and environmental pressures.

Mark Rosenzweig
Editor in Chief
[email protected]

About the Author

Mark Rosenzweig | Former Editor-in-Chief

Mark Rosenzweig is Chemical Processing's former editor-in-chief. Previously, he was editor-in-chief of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers' magazine Chemical Engineering Progress. Before that, he held a variety of roles, including European editor and managing editor, at Chemical Engineering. He has received a prestigious Neal award from American Business Media. He earned a degree in chemical engineering from The Cooper Union. His collection of typewriters now exceeds 100, and he has driven a 1964 Studebaker Gran Turismo Hawk for more than 40 years.

Sponsored Recommendations

Heat Recovery: Turning Air Compressors into an Energy Source

More than just providing plant air, they're also a useful source of heat, energy savings, and sustainable operations.

Controls for Industrial Compressed Air Systems

Master controllers leverage the advantages of each type of compressor control and take air system operations and efficiency to new heights.

Discover Your Savings Potential with the Kaeser Toolbox

Discover your compressed air station savings potential today with our toolbox full of calculators that will help you determine how you can optimize your system!

The Art of Dryer Sizing

Read how to size compressed air dryers with these tips and simple calculations and correction factors from air system specialists.