Home » Articles » Rosenzweig

Publishing of Research Draws Government Attention

Academic journals face significant new editorial and financial pressures.

By Mark Rosenzweig, Editor in Chief

In December, in an unprecedented move, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) intervened in the publication of two research articles on work to enhance the transmission of bird flu in mammals.

"Currently, H5N1 avian influenza virus — the strain commonly referred to as 'bird flu' — rarely infects humans and does not spread easily from person to person. However, many scientists and public health officials are concerned that the virus could evolve in nature into a form that is transmissible among humans — an event that could potentially make this deadly virus an extremely serious global public health threat. Thus research on factors that can affect the transmissibility of the H5N1 virus is critically important to international efforts to prepare and prevent threats to public health," says an HHS press statement.

"While the public health benefits of such research can be important, certain information obtained through such studies has the potential to be misused for harmful purposes. The National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity (NSABB) — an independent expert committee that advises the Department of Health and Human Services and other Federal departments and agencies on matters of biosecurity — completed a review of two unpublished manuscripts describing NIH [National Institutes of Health]-funded research on the transmissibility of H5N1….

"Following its review, the NSABB decided to recommend that HHS ask the authors of the reports and the editors of the journals that were considering publishing the reports to make changes in the manuscripts. Due to the importance of the findings to the public health and research communities, the NSABB recommended that the general conclusions highlighting the novel outcome be published, but that the manuscripts not include the methodological and other details that could enable replication of the experiments by those who would seek to do harm," adds the statement.

The editors of the two journals, Nature and Science, have indicated willingness to comply with the non-binding HHS request.

As an editor, I view with concern any attempt by government to influence what is published. Here, though, the intervention seems justified. I'm certainly more confident in that because scientific experts on an advisory board, rather than bureaucrats, prompted the move. I expect that such interference will remain rare and limited to papers based on government-funded research.

Government may pose a more-far-reaching threat to many research journals. "Innovation and Research Strategy for Growth," a report presented to the UK Parliament in December, takes a stance that challenges the business model of most academic journals — i.e., charging a hefty subscription price to a limited, specialized audience.

"The Government, in line with our overarching commitment to transparency and open data, is committed to ensuring that publicly-funded research should be accessible free of charge. Free and open access to taxpayer-funded research offers significant social and economic benefits by spreading knowledge, raising the prestige of UK research and encouraging technology transfer. At the moment, such research is often difficult to find and expensive to access. This can defeat the original purpose of taxpayer-funded academic research and limits understanding and innovation. We have already committed… to facilitate data mining of published research. This could have substantial benefits, for example in tackling diseases. But we need to go much further if, as a nation, we are to gain the full potential benefits of publicly-funded research," the report stresses.

"Government will work with partners, including the publishing industry, to achieve free access to publicly-funded research as soon as possible and will set an example itself…"

In an interview in The Guardian, Science Minister David Willetts notes: "…We want to move to open access, but in a way that ensures that peer review and publishing continues as a function. It needs to be paid for somehow. One of the clear options is to shift to a system from [one in] which university libraries pay for journals to one in which the academics pay to publish. But then you need to shift the funding so the academics could afford to pay to publish."

If the UK initiative takes hold and other governments adopt a similar approach, research journals face serious adjustments and topsy-turvy finances. But open access may be worth the price.

MARK ROSENZWEIG is Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief. You can e-mail him at mrosenzweig@putman.net.

More From This Perspective

Publishing of Research Draws Government Attention
01/18/2012
Academic journals face significant new editorial and financial pressures.

The Big Apple Has A Peach of an Idea
12/19/2011
An audacious plan for a new applied-science graduate school attracts major universities.

There's a New Buzz on Campus
11/14/2011
A leading chemical company spurs academic research on traditional topics.

Italian Trial Covers Some Shaky Ground
10/18/2011
Case about advising public on earthquake risk has broader implications.

We Must Improve Safety and Security
09/29/2011
Better performance demands more than add-on equipment and software.

Get Your Proper Bearings
08/25/2011
Some common misconceptions can lead you into trouble.

Partnership Aims to Bolster U.S. Industry
07/14/2011
Federal initiative and free software focus on improving manufacturing .

How Do You Picture Safety?
06/09/2011
An unusual photo contest seeks your creative take on the topic

New Museum Really Adds Up
05/11/2011
Institution debuting next year intends to inspire interest in mathematics.

Could You Be the Ultimate Plant Manager?
04/07/2011
A new online game lets you compete against others to achieve the best performing site.

Biofuels Development Gets a Boost
03/14/2011
Facility promises to ease scale-up efforts.

Is Water The New Carbon?
02/09/2011
Companies face increasing pressure to disclose, as well as optimize, water use.

Don't Neglect Energy Auditing
01/17/2011
Not properly monitoring compressed air and steam systems is foolish and can be costly.

Gas Buoys U.S. Chemical Industry Outlook
12/20/2010
Abundant supplies of domestic natural gas may open up more feedstock opportunities.

We Can Learn a Lot from Dow Chemical
11/16/2010
Taking a broader view can improve already impressive EH&S performance.

Don't Slight the Simple Stuff
10/28/2010
Vessels and other mundane assets can pose significant risks.

Is Starting in Production a Wise Career Move?
09/16/2010
The first job a newly minted engineer takes may have long-term impact.

We Need More Engineers in Congress
08/11/2010
People with technical backgrounds likely can enhance legislation.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings October 2009: Industry Safety Initiative Deserves Applause
07/19/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief notes that the American Chemistry Council is moving proactively to influence legislation.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings November 2009: Take a Safe Approach to Safety Equipment
07/19/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief urges readers to not risk finding out whether bargains really will work right.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings December 2009: Grasp All the Lessons of Bhopal
07/19/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief is worried that industry still hasn't adequately addressed one factor behind the disaster.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings January 2010: Trade Shows Require Rethinking
07/13/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief points out that chemical companies continue to face financial pressures. With funds tight for capital expenditures, there's less motivation to send engineers to the show, especially when firms also are curtailing non-essential travel to save money.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings March 2010: U.S. Lead in Science and Engineering Erodes
07/13/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief reports Asian countries are gaining momentum according to the National Science Board's report to the President and Congress on the state of science, engineering and technology in the U.S.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings February 2010: We Need Another A.C. Gilbert
07/13/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief remembers when many engineers of his generation played with Erector Sets when they were growing up.

Look on the Positive Side Of The Oil Spill
07/12/2010
The Gulf of Mexico disaster may prompt some welcome developments.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings May 2010: Obama Tackles Safety Board Vacancies
07/06/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief notes that President Barack Obama announced his first nominees for the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB): Rafael Moure-Eraso, Ph.D., to be chair and Mark A. Griffon to be a member. If confirmed, these appointments would bring the board back to a full complement of five members.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings April 2010: Sustainability Proves Its Worth
07/06/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief discusses a study that points to considerable cash flow benefits from better performance. Effectiveness in using resources differs markedly among some major chemical companies and that difference has a significant financial dimension, according to a recent report "Sustainable Value Creation by Chemical Companies."

Rosenzweig's Ramblings June 2010: Plant Security Deserves More Attention
06/23/2010
Chemical Processing's Editor-in-Chief has visited more than a few facilities in his time and, frequently, first impressions can be telling. For instance, it's often apparent from a cursory view how well a site is maintained and the quality of housekeeping.

Marshalltown Really Builds Upon a Legacy
06/03/2010
State-of-the-art valve testing facility occupies site of historic factory

Obama Tackles Safety Board Vacancies
04/06/2010
President nominates new chair and member for Chemical Safety Board.

Sustainability Proves Its Worth
03/15/2010
Study points to considerable cash flow benefits from better performance.

U.S. Lead in Science and Engineering Erodes
02/15/2010
Biennial report points to gains particularly by Asian countries.

We Need Another A.C. Gilbert
01/06/2010
Toy maker knew how to interest children in science and engineering.

Grasp All the Lessons of Bhopal
11/24/2009
Industry still hasn't adequately addressed one factor behind the disaster.

Industry Safety Initiative Deserves Applause
09/14/2009
The American Chemistry Council is moving proactively to influence legislation.

Call It "Dereliction of Duty"
08/27/2009
Chemical companies too often don't exercise enough care when deactivating units.

Make the Most of Your Summer Reading
07/16/2009
Two new books provide important insights and guidance about plant safety.

Getting the Right Total Isn’t Easy
06/29/2009
Our vendor rankings account for numerous current and retired brands.

Succession Planning: Avoid a Dumb Move
05/27/2009
Stinting on capturing the expertise of departing employees is a false economy.

Have You Heard the One about the Chemical Engineer?
04/23/2009
There’s really nothing funny about our image as technocrats.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings March 2009: Spend Slack Time Smartly
04/09/2009
You finally may have a chance to focus on a variety of worthwhile projects.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings February 2009: Convince A Child To Explore Engineering
04/09/2009
American kids need more awareness of engineering careers -- and a better education.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings January 2009 : How Should Industry Tackle Threats?
04/09/2009
New report promotes inherently safer technology for hazardous facilities.

Chemical Engineers Crow
03/18/2009
New Web site celebrates the profession's past and prospective achievements

Spend Slack Time Smartly
03/02/2009
You finally may have a chance to focus on a variety of worthwhile projects.

Give An Enduring Gift | Rosenzweig's Ramblings December 2008
02/24/2009
Donating time and expertise can transform the lives of people in the developing world.

Convince A Child to Explore Engineering
01/21/2009
American kids need more awareness of engineering careers — and a better education.

How Should Industry Tackle Threats?
12/22/2008
New report promotes inherently safer technology for hazardous facilities.

Give an Enduring Gift
12/03/2008
Donating time and technical expertise can transform the lives of people in the developing world.

Houston, We Have Lift-off
11/04/2008
Several interesting new products got launched at ISA Expo.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings: Chemical Processing Turns 70
10/24/2008
Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig notes that chemical manufacturing has changed dramatically over the years and so, too, has Chemical Processing.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings: Wireless Takes Center Stage
10/23/2008
Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig explains how an intrepid reporter finds how wireless technology is improving plant performance.

Rosenzweig's Ramblings: Make the Most of Control System Migration
10/22/2008
Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig notes that vintage systems now are subject to stresses for which they were never designed.

Chemical Safety Board Gets Rebuke
10/10/2008
Recent report points to failings and necessary remedial actions

Rosenzweig's Ramblings: ICI Fades Into History
09/23/2008
Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig laments the loss of one of the greatest names in the chemical industry.

Chemical Processing turns 70
08/27/2008
A focus right from the start on “practical usefulness” has led to longevity

Chemical Processing Magazine celebrates 70 years
08/11/2008
A focus right from the start on “practical usefulness” has led to longevity

Make the most of control system migration
06/17/2008
The right strategy may lead to significant improvements in plant performance

Rosenzweig's Ramblings: Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook
06/04/2008
Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig lauds the release of a new edition of a long-time engineering favorite.

From the Editor: ICI fades into history
06/02/2008
One of the greatest names in the chemical industry is disappearing

What’s needed in process automation?
05/05/2008
A recent survey of end users provides an extensive wish list

Vendors Should See the Light
04/15/2008
Maintenance staffs would welcome warning LEDs on equipment

New president will grapple with greenhouse gases
03/13/2008
All the leading potential nominees favor “cap and trade”

Deflect a double whammy
02/13/2008
Consider new options for tackling economic and environmental concerns.

Just call it alchemical engineering
02/05/2008
Technology really can transform worthless materials into gold.

Deflect a double whammy
02/04/2008
Consider new options for tackling economic and environmental concerns.

New edition of pre-eminent handbook released
12/10/2007
For more than 70 years, if one reference has epitomized what chemical engineering is all about it’s been "Perry’s Chemical Engineers' Handbook." Now, a new edition — the first in a decade — has just come out.

Celebrity cheers on U.S. manufacturers
10/29/2007
Editor Mark Rosenzweig discusses how an actor is drawing attention to thriving plants and the importance of manufacturing, in this month's From the Editor column.

Exceed environmental expectations
09/27/2007
The chemical industry is making environmental progress but needs stretch goals, says Mark Rosenzweig, in this month's From the Editor column.

China teems with harmful exports
08/28/2007
Problems with Chinese manufacturing go well beyond defective and dangerous products, Mark Rosenzweig, editor in chief, notes in this month's installment of From the Editor.

Attack equipment problems along several fronts
08/01/2007
A successful approach demands looking at more than maintenance, advises Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig, in his monthly column.

Get safety under control
07/06/2007
Check out a different approach to safety analysis and a valuable new reference in this month's column from Editor Mark Rosenzweig.

Hardening plants is hard work
06/06/2007
Industry should welcome the new, first-ever federal security rules, advises Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig in this month's From the Editor column.

Distillation deserves a high profile
04/30/2007
Columns often present abundant opportunities for improvement, says Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig in his monthly column.

Publishing suffers a deep loss
04/12/2007
Longest-serving editor embodied the best of the profession. Mark Rosenzweig pays tribute to the late Nick Chopey.

Are companies ready to break the cycle?
03/01/2007
Executives say chemical industry must focus more on employee retention, according to Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig, in his monthly column.

The chemical industry needs fresh eyes
01/30/2007
Team looking at BP’s safety failings benefited from its diverse membership. Editor Mark Rosenzweig interviews panel member Dennis Hendershot for an insider's perspective.

We’re starting the new year off right
01/03/2007
The magazine and Web site are gaining significant enhancements. We’ve ratcheted up our efforts to identify ways of better serving you. As a result, we’re launching several features that we hope will make Chemical Processing and ChemicalProcessing.com even more valuable to you.

NeSSI’s success should be a lock
11/29/2006
The New Sampling/Sensor Initiative or NeSSI that replaces tubing, fittings and other hardware in a sampling system with miniature modular components makes sense. Enhancements now in the works should assure its success.

Wireless devices may get a shake up
10/31/2006
Last month’s ISA Expo in Houston clearly showed how much attention wireless technology is attracting. However, concern about the reliability and life of batteries remains an issue. That’s why harvested or scavenged power is attracting interest.

Security poses an inherent industry dilemma
09/21/2006
Industry faces the threat of draconian demands from Congress as chemical plants remain an attractive targets for terrorism attacks, according to Mark Rosenzweig, editor in chief of Chemical Processing.

Curriculum change isn’t enough
09/11/2006
Chemical engineering students deserve better teachers, according to Chemical Processing's Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig.

Product stewardship takes a grave turn
08/17/2006
European Union mandates have impacted products produced and sold in the U.S., and will ultimately affect the chemical industry, according to Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig.

Mississippi plants show their grit
06/28/2006
As the first anniversary of Hurricane Katrina approaches, life remains far from normal in many areas of the Gulf Coast. Amid the destruction, though, some hard-hit chemical plants provide proof of what can be accomplished.

Let’s cut through barbed wireless
06/16/2006
Divergent standards could snag efficient deployment of devices.

Typewriters send a somber message
06/07/2006
Lack of skilled technicians and parts can doom otherwise useful equipment.

Protect the perimeter and the process
04/12/2006
A visit to Honeywell's Geismar plant reminded Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig how to integrate security and control.

Repair your maintenance program
02/28/2006
Take a fresh look at how to improve staff productivity and skills.

Savor your slide rule
02/20/2006
This long-time symbol of engineering has retained its value, says Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig in his monthly column.

Hard lessons worth sharing
01/24/2006
Editor-in-Chief Mark Rosenzweig writes that the causes of two incidents should get attention from other processors.

Let’s heat up efforts to save energy
12/21/2005
Ample opportunities to boost efficiency certainly exist at most plants.

Vaaler Award Winners
11/27/2005
Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig congratulates the winners for CP's annual Vaaler awards, given to the products and services that most improve the operations and economics of plants.

SOCMA makes a momentous move
10/25/2005
Replacing Responsible Care is anything but irresponsible.

What price is right?
09/27/2005
Minimizing costs is only one part of the economic equation for profitability.

Take safety up a notch
08/25/2005
There’s still room to improve industry’s good safety performance, says Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig in his monthly column. Mechanical integrity programs generally need more attention.

Going from erector sets to chemical plants and beyond
07/25/2005

Be careful when getting bids
06/23/2005
When getting bids, don't invite trouble, as well as proposals.

Chemical industry and academia must move closer
05/25/2005
The 7th World Congress of Chemical Engineering is nearly upon us, and "industry people" need to have a larger presence at these types of meetings, says Editor in Chief Mark Rosenzweig.

German company proud of chemical ties
04/04/2005
While American companies make an effort to rebuff their chemical industry ties, BASF embraces them.

The Lark provides a serious lesson for the chemical industry
03/10/2005
The key to the long-term vitality of a chemical corporation does not lie in its business acumen, but in its ability to continue to make innovative chemicals. Editor in chief Mark Rosenzweig says executives should show more enthusiasm for this process.

Process management: Raise an alarm about alarms
01/19/2005
Sure, having more alarms is a plus if they contribute to better plant operation. But nowadays, more and more plants have numerous alarms that are causing more trouble than they are worth.

Let's close some glaring gaps
12/06/2004
We need effective collaborative efforts to address technical and professional issues

Adapt or perish
11/08/2004
Embrace changes in our profession to survive and succeed

It's time to untangle the Web
11/05/2004
Our new site goes well beyond the magazine and provides focused, actionable information

Stay ahead of your peers
10/07/2004
Earning an MBA can take your career in new directions

Where are chemical engineers headed?
08/05/2004
Will opportunities in today's "hot" sectors , such as pharmaceuticals and biotechnology, among others, allow chemical engineering to continue to thrive?

Let's honor real gold-medal performances
07/01/2004

Go outside for internal standards
06/01/2004

The evolution continues
05/13/2004

Sophistication only goes so far
04/02/2004

A disheartening disconnect
03/29/2004

A dangerous visit
03/03/2004

Starting the Year Off Right
03/01/2004

A baffling issue?
12/18/2003

A welcome package
12/05/2003

Focus, not hocus-pocus
10/23/2003