Perspectives: Process Puzzler

Process Puzzler: Hold Off on a Hydrogen Hike

Consider other options than increasing the feed of fresh hydrogen

*THIS MONTH’S PUZZLER* We’re planning to increase the capacity of a diesel hydrotreater unit by replacing part of the recycle hydrogen currently used with fresh hydrogen from an existing 1,200-psig system. The header begins as an 18-in., schedule-80 pipe. The control valves are each fed from a line right off the header.* Figure 1* (http://goo.gl/S801qN) shows what the header system looks like: the 1,600-ft line now handles a flow of 868 million standard cubic feet per day (MMSCFD) of hydrogen; the expansion will raise the total flow to 918 MMSCFD. One branch delivers 5 MMSCFD to isomerization. Another branch services a variety of hydrotreaters. It runs 2,500 ft and furnishes 200 MMSCFD to a hydrocracker, and then goes 3,100 ft where a common branch feeds two diesel hydrotreaters, which get 75 MMSCFD and 63 MMSCFD, respectively, and an ultra-low-sulfur diesel (ULSD) hydrotreater, which is fed 75 MMSCFD. After the diesel header, the line decreases in size to 12 in. and goes 2,700 ft to a kerosene hydrotreater fed 85 MMSCFD. It then continues 2,600 ft to a naphtha hydrotreater that gets 75 MMSCFD and to another header that delivers 140 MMSCFD to a gasoline hydrotreater and 150 MMSCFD to a fluid catalytic cracker (FCC) hydrotreater. The expansion will increase the hydrogen flow to the diesel hydrotreater 2 to 113 MMSCFD from 63; the % open for the control valve only will increase to 76% from 61%, so the project has been approved. The flows are all nominal-high values. A production engineer now is questioning the idea of increasing the fresh H2 output; he’s afraid it will put a strain on the system. What do you think?   *LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE* Anytime you increase the system demand by 50 MMSCFD, i.e., 6%, with a pressure control valve (PCV) already at 72%, there will be trouble. Obviously, the compressor supplying the H2 and the control valve are sized together. With higher flow, head will decrease eventually. The rise to 79% open for the PCV probably is caused by a drop in the compressor head.

Read more

More from this perspective...

Title

Process Puzzler: Put Railcar Loading Back on Track

Readers suggest how to stop serious safety snags.

04/21/2010

Process Puzzler: Replace the Tank

A fiberglass vessel isn't appropriate for the intended use.

11/20/2012

Process Puzzler: Restore Reboiler Reliability

Readers recommend ways to keep a thermosiphon operating properly

05/30/2013

Process Puzzler: Root Out Rumbling

Measurements can confirm the cause of the problem in the fiber-glass piping.

11/11/2010

Process Puzzler: Serve up better column operation

Readers tackle Chemical Processing's process puzzler question and offer tips about how to keep a stripper column from flooding.

12/21/2004

Process Puzzler: Sidestep a Scale-up Scare

Readers grapple with a reactor production change.

03/04/2009

Process Puzzler: Soothe a Skittish Supervisor

Readers weigh the wisdom of cladding exchanger tubes to answer last month's Process Puzzler.

12/16/2008

Process Puzzler: Sort Out a Steam Condensate System

Readers suggest ways to address water hammer and other problems.

10/07/2013

Process Puzzler: Spike Tank Spikes

Readers suggest how to avoid column feed tank problems.

05/31/2011

Process Puzzler: Tame Tower Temperature Turmoil

Start-up conditions may provide key insights about what's causing problems.

09/20/2012

Process Puzzler: Tell the Bosses the Truth

Management’s goal for a material balance likely isn’t feasible.

10/15/2009

Process Puzzler: Veto the Proposed Vent Scrubber

Its design suffers from serious mechanical and safety deficiencies.

07/31/2013

Pumping LPG: Take A Load Off Loading

Readers suggest how to avoid problems in pumping liquefied petroleum gas.

02/28/2013

Quell a Quality Control Confrontation

Readers recommend improvements for a pH control process

10/27/2008

September 2008 Process Puzzler: Kayo a Drum Problem

Readers suggest ways to improve the performance of a pot

08/13/2008

September Process Puzzler: Fix a Fast Fouling Filter

Readers suggest ways to improve operation and safety. Also included is November's Process Puzzler Question.

09/05/2008

September Process Puzzler: Uncovering cause of solid build-up

Readers offer suggestions to improve reliability of a vibrating screen in Chemical Processing's monthly Process Puzzler feature.

09/14/2006

September Process Puzzler: Will steam get a plant into hot water?

Readers offer advice about switching a clean-in-place procedure.

08/31/2007

Silo Holds Mysteries

Readers ponder why an old tank failed.

08/23/2011

Slop Oil System Is Too Sloppy

Addressing safety and environmental issues will demand major modifications

08/28/2013