Perspectives: Plant InSites

Steam Systems: Simple Solutions Can Prompt Complex Problems

Steam systems are especially susceptible to developing difficulties

By Andrew Sloley, Contributing Editor

Related Steam Solutions Content
Over time what seems like a simple solution to a problem often evolves into a larger predicament. Accumulated shortcuts metastasize into major difficulties. In complex plants many of these larger problems ultimately appear in utility systems. Steam systems, in particular, often attract simple solutions and then, because of them, suffer serious troubles.

Consider what befell a large site that originally had conventional condensate handling. As plant operations pushed capacity, lots of services had difficulty in keeping the condensate at high enough pressure to return it to the boiler house. So, many steam exchangers dumped condensate to the concrete pads in the units. In winter the condensate froze, turning large areas of the site into skating rinks. Something had to be done — so the plant installed a fourth, low-pressure condensate system.
Figure 1. Too simple a solution -- Low pressure of
this system led to condensate flashing — and
major problems.
Click on image for larger diagram.

Adding a new condensate system doesn’t necessarily create problems. How you add the system may. The plant buried a vessel for condensate collection on the new system (Figure 1). To minimize pressure, the vessel had an atmospheric vent. A submerged pump sent condensate to the boiler house. A large amount of excess capacity was provided to deal with future expansions.

Condensate flashes when depressurized. The amount of flashing as condensate enters the new drum depends upon the upstream pressure of the condensate. To eliminate equipment, most of the plant’s steam heaters used partially flooded bundles to control exchanger duty (“Don’t Let Heater Control Get you Steamed,” www.ChemicalProcessing.com/articles/2004/81.html). One consequence of using condensate level in a partially flooded bundle for duty control is that the exchanger pressure is always at a maximum on the steam side.
Because increasing exchanger duties created further problems with the other condensate systems, more and more condensate sources were routed to the new atmospheric-pressure system (the one with the extra capacity). The combination of partially flooded exchangers and the low pressure of the new system maximized the pressure drop between the normal consumer and the condensate recovery drum. Significant amounts of condensate vaporized.

The condensate vaporization created two problems. First, much of the steam was vented. The same winter conditions that led the dumped condensate to freeze also led the vented steam to freeze out as icicles on surrounding equipment. Over weeks a large area crusted with ice developed. This caused significant safety and operating problems. (Plus the vented steam is a lost opportunity for energy savings.) Second, the volume expansion from the condensate flashing started to create pressure drop and erosion problems in the low pressure condensate lines.

Placing strategically located intermediate flash drums and replacing the buried drum with a properly designed condensate recovery system solved the plant problems. Steam from flashing condensate was recovered close to groups of major steam consumers. This dramatically reduced condensate flashing in the existing plant lines. The recovered steam went to the next lower pressure level. The energy savings alone paid for much of the work required.

Don’t let simple solutions grow over time into unmanageable problems. Keep in mind that eventually systems reach their limits. At that point, make a step change to improve plant operations instead of letting poor situations fester.

More from this perspective...

Title

Take a Load Off Loading

Some pipelines may benefit from more than "optimum" insulation.

 

Plant InSites: Come Up With a Solid Estimate

Use geometry to figure out the amount of material in storage or equipment.

 

Assess the Gravity of the Situation

Flow systems without pumps demand particular attention.

 

Improve Your Plant's Prospects

Keep economics and the lifecycle stage of a facility in mind .

 

How Important is Piping Symmetry?

Designers should consider the impact of unequal flows in branches.

 

Watch Out for Two-Phase Flow

Process performance can suffer dramatically when a liquid flashes unexpectedly.

 

Rethink Reactor Temperature Control

Cascade strategy offers simplicity and fast response.

 

Software: Show Some Skepticism

Calculated results require critical analysis.

 

Properly Trigger Standby Pumps

A pressure signal works for many but not all situations.

 

Don’t let parallel pumps cross you up

Small differences with parallel pumps can lead to big difficulties, according to Andrew Sloley in this month's Plant InSites column.

 

Make sure you’ve got a good flange match

Standard large-diameter flanges don’t necessarily mate. Andrew Sloley provides insight in this month's Plant Insites column.

 

Put V-cone Meters on Your Short List

 

Consider Compact Reboilers

Several types of heat exchangers can save space

 

Reliability and Maintenance: Don’t Slight Strainers

These simple but often essential devices deserve adequate attention

 

Think Straight About Orifice Plates

Insufficient flow conditioning often undermines measurement accuracy.

 

Vacuum System Fix Fizzles

Use of scavenged equipment leads to problems.

 

Get Valid Samples

Materials’ selection and piping design markedly can affect results.

 

Don't Let a Second Liquid Phase Faze You

 

Properly Position Interlock Valves

The obvious location may not be the most cost effective

 

Baffles Needn't Be Baffling

Clear criteria determine their design for drums to separate three phases.