Perspectives: Plant InSites

Centrifugal Pumps: Fight Flow Recirculation

But first understand why the phenomenon occurs in centrifugal pumps.

By Andrew Sloley, Contributing Editor

1405 flow recirculation buttonSuction recirculation can undermine operation of a centrifugal pump at low flows. The pump’s suction specific speed and suction energy can provide insights about potential difficulties (see: “Cut Pump Speed to Cut Problems"). Variable frequency drives (VFDs) frequently can provide a solution (“Consider VFDs for Centrifugal Pumps").

Fixing suction recirculation problems often costs money. Typically, getting the funding requires convincing the holder of the purse strings of what’s the real cause of a problem.

Many people have trouble grasping the idea that flow can go backward within a centrifugal pump. Over the years, I’ve often struggled to find a fundamentally correct but simple explanation.

First, we must realize that what’s simple to a mechanical engineer may appear complicated to a chemical engineer. So, let’s explain the phenomenon in ways both groups can understand.

For mechanical engineers, a centrifugal pump increases the pressure of a liquid stream. The natural direction of fluid flow is from high pressure to low pressure. Fluid flow through the pump occurs because the rotating impeller provides velocity to generate pressure. The velocity gradient creates the discharge pressure.

In a centrifugal pump, liquid enters the suction eye at the center of the impeller disc. The liquid changes velocity before exiting the pump at the impeller periphery. To deal with the geometry of flow from the center to the edge of the impeller and changes in velocity, the flow passage shape changes. Figure 1 shows an end-on view of an impeller that’s rotating counter-clockwise and Figure 2 shows a side view.

Inlet flow contacts the impeller’s leading edge at a specific incidence angle (Figure 1). Vector analysis of liquid flow directions shows the incidence angle affects eddy formation. As flow rates drop, the eddies formed become larger. Eventually, eddies can create partial flow from the pump discharge to the pump suction. The local flow pattern follows the outline shown in Figure 1.

For chemical engineers, it’s better to consider how pump flow patterns interact with material balance boundaries. A series of material balance boundaries through the pump always will have the same net flow as the pump suction flow. If pump suction flow drops, the net flow through any cross section of the pump drops. Because typical fluids are incompressible at most conditions, this creates an absolute requirement that average velocity in any cross section varies linearly with flow rate.

However, close to the pressure edge (the leading surface) of the impeller, impeller speed sets liquid velocity. If average liquid velocity must drop but velocity in that area of the flow passage is close to constant, velocity in other areas must fall even more than the average. At some point, when average velocity decreases enough, the flow direction in areas far from the impeller’s leading edge must reverse to meet the average velocity requirement. Figure 2 shows a schematic of net flow in a pump at its best efficiency point (BEP) and at a low flow condition (0.25 of the BEP). At low rates, the flow passages in the pump are simply too big. Nevertheless, they must be filled with liquid. Flow recirculation results.

Flow recirculation can damage the impeller due to cavitation caused by vaporization in the low-pressure regions that recirculation creates. Flow recirculation also stresses pump components with unbalanced forces and vibration.

Both mechanical and process changes can reduce the consequences of flow recirculation.

Mechanical solutions focus on the pump. For instance, impeller-volute-geometry matching and vane-angle, leading-edge and inlet-eye modifications, as well as pump speed changes all can improve pump flexibility. However, each affects efficiency, discharge head and capacity differently.

One process modification adds a recirculation loop to keep the pump out of the low flow region. Recirculation systems require extra equipment (piping, restriction orifices, control valves, etc.). In my experience, many flow control loops are abandoned due to maintenance costs or ignorance of their importance.

Another process modification provides excess suction head to the pump. This helps prevent cavitation-like damage. Even the low-pressure regions in the pump have sufficient head to keep the fluid above its bubble point. However, extra suction head doesn’t solve stress and vibration problems. At some point, pump vibration may exceed good practice values. Extra stress and vibration decrease mean time between repair and mean time between failure. Maintenance costs rise with high vibration and stress. Reduced operating speed lowers vibration and pump loads.

While it may not be a perfect solution, switching to a VFD can benefit nearly every centrifugal pump service suffering from inlet recirculation.

Picking the right option requires a thorough analysis of both mechanical and process constraints and costs.


ANDREW SLOLEY is a Chemical Processing Contributing Editor. You can email him at ASloley@putman.net

More from this perspective...

Title

Stripper Bares All

Analysis reveals how operating practices compounded design mistakes

11/21/2008

Steam Systems: Simple Solutions Can Prompt Complex Problems

Steam systems are especially susceptible to developing difficulties

12/23/2008

Spot problems with adsorbents

The longer-than-expected life of an adsorbent points up the need to always assess the consequences of system additions. While sometimes this may involve detailed calculations, simply looking to the laws of physics can eliminate potential headaches.

08/14/2006

Software: Show Some Skepticism

Calculated results require critical analysis.

06/14/2010

Sidestep side-draw control surprises

The simplest approach to control side-draw distillation columns uses flow control on the side product. This solution, however, is not ideal for all side-draw control situations.

07/01/2004

Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchanger: Pick the Right Side

Allocating fluids in a tubular exchanger demands care.

10/23/2013

Select the Right Reboiler

Understand the strengths and weaknesses of various options.

06/04/2012

Save a bundle solving pressure-drop problems

Pressure drop in compressor-suction and interstage coolers often creates problems. In some cases, just a few pounds of extra pressure drop make a revamp unworkable.

11/04/2004

Right Vacuum Control Choice Takes the Pressure Off

Choosing the proper recycle stream for regulation is crucial

08/07/2008

Rethink Reactor Temperature Control

Cascade strategy offers simplicity and fast response.

07/13/2010

Put V-cone Meters on Your Short List

06/10/2013

Properly Trigger Standby Pumps

A pressure signal works for many but not all situations.

05/06/2010

Properly protect centrifugal pumps

Consider various factors when selecting how to guard against low flow, Andrew Sloley says in this month's Plant Insites column.

07/11/2007

Properly Position Interlock Valves

The obvious location may not be the most cost effective

10/16/2012

Properly Assess Energy Recovery Projects

Impact on other operations and transfer prices may alter the economics.

03/09/2011

Process Engineering: Poor compressor design puts pressure on pumps

When a poor compressor design put too much pressure on the pumps, a new solution had to be constructed.  Sometimes the ideal solution is just an intricate compromise.

01/18/2005

Process Engineering: Inspect with your mind, not just your eyes

A thorough inspection of plant equipment following tiny installations can prevent a lot of future problems. Go beyond just checking for compliance with drawings when looking at hardware and physically look at the equipment itself.

03/11/2005

Preheater points out the value of cooling off

Lack of attention to detail in conceptual design can hide many sins. Put the problem aside and then ponder it again. A fresh look may lead to an even better solution.

05/12/2004

Plant InSites: Look Beyond the Lore

Don’t rely on recollections about how a unit had performed

10/10/2008

Plant InSites: Don’t Make Problems for Your Plant

Local fabrication may seem attractive but can degrade performance.

10/22/2009