Perspectives: Plant InSites

Consider VFDs for Centrifugal Pumps

Such drives may provide energy savings and avoid operating problems.

By Andrew Sloley, contributing editor

Variable frequency drives (VFD) offer a useful control option for the motors of many types of reciprocating and centrifugal equipment. For instance, VFDs can deal with centrifugal-pump suction recirculation problems; running at lower speed can help reduce damage and operating difficulties.

To understand how to apply VFDs effectively, you must know the characteristics of the system and the equipment. So, let’s look at a general procedure that can serve as a good starting point for evaluating specific cases — realizing, of course, that it can’t cover every possibility.

To evaluate a VFD application, we need the following:
• system information on pressure drop versus flow;
• pump performance curves for the existing impeller;
• pump performance curves for the maximum impeller; and
• pump inlet eye dimensions.

Ideally, the performance curves should include pump head, pump efficiency and net positive suction head (NPSH) required versus flow rate. Pump heads and efficiencies at various speeds are useful.

Often, only incomplete information is available. So, you may need to extrapolate to fill in missing information.

ANALYSIS PROCEDURE
A VFD evaluation involves multiple steps, each looking at a specific item. Below are the basic steps. (Some cases won’t need every step while others may require additional ones. The information available and needed as well as the number of cases to be evaluated determine what must be done.)

1. Define the system curve.
2. Examine the pump curve for the existing impeller at fixed speed.
3. Plot a flow rate versus speed curve for the installed impeller.
4. Determine the best efficiency point (BEP) flow rate versus speed for the maximum impeller.
5. Examine NPSH versus flow rate.
6. Plot flow rate versus suction specific speed (Nss) for using the VFD to control.
7. Define operating fraction of BEP flow versus Nss.
8. Compare the operating flow fraction versus Nss to good practice.
9. Evaluate pump suction energy to determine the NPSH margin.
10. Check power available.
11. If the results of operating flow fraction versus Nssand pump suction energy evaluation are unacceptable, assess alternative solutions.

The system curve plots the required differential head versus flow rate. The system curve includes both static head requirements for elevation and pressure change and dynamic head requirements from pressure drop.

Most often, only a pump curve at a single fixed speed is available. This typically is a nominal 1,800 or 3,600 rpm for 60-Hz motors and 1,500 or 3,000 rpm for 50-Hz motors. (In such cases, you can generate curves for other speeds by using the affinity law: pump head varies as the square of pump speed.)

Plotting the pump curve for fixed-speed operation shows how much savings a VFD might provide. If the pump curve and system curve don’t intersect at a higher flow than for the given pump, the pump is too small. A VFD can help here by raising the pump’s operating speed to a higher-than-standard rpm so the pump curve and system curve intersect at the desired flow rate — but at the expense of higher power requirements.

Evaluating pump performance requires a BEP versus speed curve for the maximum diameter impeller. BEP flow typically varies linearly with both pump diameter and speed.

An NPSH curve also is necessary. If only available at one point, NPSH can be extrapolated based on the flow rate squared. However, this will underestimate NPSH requirements at low flow rates. So, it’s always best to use an actual NPSH curve.

Based on pump speed versus flow, plot a curve of Nss versus flow [1]. Also plot a curve of fraction of BEP flow (at that speed for the maximum impeller). Figure 1 shows an example plot of flow versus Nss and fraction of BEP flow versus Nss.

Good practice suggests a maximum NSS of roughly 8,500 for a turndown of 50% on a centrifugal pump. Consult ANSI/HI 9.6.3-2012 [2], which is the most commonly accepted good-practice definition for flow flexibility on centrifugal pumps, to get an idea of the reasonable operating range of a specific pump with a VFD.

Suction energy [3] is another, more recent, measure of suitability for running at low liquid rates. So, compare the pump performance to suction energy values. The lower the suction energy, the more likely the pump will operate successfully.

The pump efficiency curve varies with the percent of BEP. Use the efficiency curve to compute power. At very low turndowns, savings might not be as great as expected. When operating above standard speeds, power consumption may be very high.

If the VFD analysis shows problems may persist, consider changing either the process or adding additional features to protect the pump from low flow [4].



ANDREW SLOLEY, is a Chemical Processing contributing editor. You can e-mail him at ASloley@putman.net

REFERENCES
1. Sloley, A. W., “Cut Pump Speed to Cut Problems,”  Chemical Processing, September 2009.
2. ANSI/HI 9.6.3-2012, “Rotodynamic (Centrifugal and Vertical) Pumps — Guideline for Allowable Operating Region,” Hydraulic Institute, Parsippany, N.J. (2012).
3. Burdis, A. R., “Improved Pump Hydraulic Selection Reduces Cavitation Risk,” p. 39, Hydrocarbon Processing, August 2004.
4. Sloley, A. W., “Properly Protect Centrifugal Pumps,”  Chemical Processing, July 2007.

More from this perspective...

Title

Assess the Gravity of the Situation

Flow systems without pumps demand particular attention.

11/09/2009

Backflush Away Fouling

Flow reversal can remove fiber buildup in heat exchangers.

11/06/2012

Baffles Needn't Be Baffling

Clear criteria determine their design for drums to separate three phases.

08/19/2013

Can you trust your sight glasses?

Sight glasses are invaluable for troubleshooting towers and checking instruments. Improper connections can take a toll on accuracy.

02/17/2006

Carefully check vendor references

Determine the differences between a cited installation and yours, Andrew Sloley, contributing editor, says in this month's Plant InSites column.

10/30/2007

Centrifugal Pumps: Avoid Surprises When Cutting Impellers

Predicting resulting centrifugal pump performance demands care

01/15/2014

Check What You're Ordering

A mistake on a purchase order can buy trouble.

02/04/2010

Choose the Correct Condenser

Consider a variety of factors when selecting a unit.

02/10/2014

Column configuration can cripple performance

The importance of having the inherent capability to meet operating requirements and enable proper instrumentation performance is stressed by Contributing Editor Andrew Sloley.

09/21/2006

Consider "Pasteurizing" Your Column

A side-draw may cut capital and energy costs for distillation.

02/12/2013

Consider Compact Reboilers

Several types of heat exchangers can save space

07/24/2012

Consider More Than Static Mixers

A number of technologies can handle pipeline mixing.

01/31/2011

Consider VFDs for Centrifugal Pumps

Such drives may provide energy savings and avoid operating problems.

03/12/2014

Control Challenges Can Pinch Energy Savings

Heat integration can make achieving effective control more difficult.

11/03/2010

Correct those disturbing lapses

Keeping liquid in a reflux drum still can prevent problems, says Andrew Sloley, in this month's Plant InSites column.

08/31/2007

Cut Pump Speed to Cut Problems

Lower rpm can translate into higher reliability.

08/10/2009

Distill Your Internals Choice

Some general guidelines can ease the selection process.

09/01/2011

Do Liquid Injection Right

A variety of factors influence performance.

01/05/2012

Do some heavy thinking about light loads

Cutting steam demand can get you into hot water, advises Contributing Editor Andrew W. Sloley, contributing editor, in this month's Plant InSites column.

10/01/2007

Don't Calculate Pressure Drops in a Vacuum

Consider flow regime boundaries and the limitations of methods.

06/08/2011