Perspectives: From the Editor

Sustainability Sustains Momentum

Drivers for use of renewable materials differ markedly between producers and users

By MARK ROSENZWEIG, Editor in Chief

The quest to improve the sustainability of chemical manufacturing takes many forms. Indeed, our recent cover story “Sustainability Gets the Spotlight,” highlighted some novel approaches. Now, a new survey underscores that chemical makers and their customers continue to move toward more sustainable products. Among its key findings: 72% of manufacturers already offer more sustainable versions of chemicals or plan to do so within two years; 80% of their customers show the same or higher interest in sustainable chemicals compared to a year ago; and 75% of chemicals users have started to market products made with more sustainable chemicals or expect to within two years.

Commissioned by Genomatica, San Diego, a company that develops and licenses bio-based processes to produce chemicals, and conducted by ICIS, London, the survey, published in September, is the third such one since 2009. It drew 958 responses, the largest number ever — in fact, 30% more than the last survey, in 2012. Inputs came both from chemical manufacturers and their customers. More than half of the respondents (53%) held senior positions such as CEO, vice president or general manager. Europe accounted for 24% of respondents and North America 22%, compared to 40% and 27%, respectively, in the last survey. In contrast, a higher level of respondents came from South East Asia (17% versus 10% in 2012) and the Middle East (10% versus 5%).

The most common sustainability initiative is process improvement, e.g., reducing energy use or waste, which was cited by 71% of respondents. It was followed by initiatives for reducing or eliminating toxic chemicals (noted by 42%), using or boosting the level of recycled raw materials (40%) and including or increasing renewables’ content in materials (37%).

People at chemical manufacturers accounted for 39% of respondents — 13% were at specialty chemical makers, 12% at commodity chemical producers, 10% at polymer manufacturers, and 4% at fine chemical and intermediate makers — compared to 55% in 2012.

Key factors when considering renewables-based production are customer demand, which was cited by 96% of respondents from chemical makers as very important (68%) or moderately important (28%), safer operations (68%/26%), minimal impact on downstream products and customers (64%/32%) and reduced operating cash cost of production (61%/34%).

Less than half of the respondents at chemical makers (43%) foresee a long-term economic advantage in switching to renewable feedstocks; 29% don’t know whether there will be an advantage.

In contrast, the main factors that consumers of chemicals said affect their consideration of using renewable-based chemicals are minimal impact on product performance or characteristics, which was cited by 96% as very important or moderately important (74%/22%), ability to differentiate products in the marketplace (92% — 61%/31%), customer demand (91% — 60%/31%), potential performance advantage (94% — 55%/39%), minimal impact on processes and facilities (94% — 53%/41%), comparable costs to currently used materials (95% — 52%/43%) and smaller environmental footprint (90% — 46%/44%).

Interest of users in sourcing renewable versions was most pronounced for specialty chemicals (cited by 52%) and polymers (48%).

When asked which developers of technology for sustainable chemicals came to mind, more respondents (32%) picked BASF, followed by Dow (25%), DuPont (21%), Bayer (12%), Genomatica (6%), Shell (5%) and ExxonMobil (5%).

BASF also topped the list of producers of sustainable chemicals that came to mind, cited by 33% of respondents, followed by Dow (28%), DuPont (20%), Bayer (13%), Sabic (6%) and Shell (6%).

BASF also drew the highest ranking when respondents were queried about their overall impression of companies with regard to sustainability. It got very positive marks from 44% of respondents and fairly positive marks from 47%. DuPont came in second (40% and 45%, respectively), closely followed by Genomatica (37%/50%). Dow received very positive ratings from 37% and fairly positive from 43% but also tallied the highest number of negative marks (17% fairly negative and 4% very negative). Bayer got very positive ratings from 36% and fairly positive ratings from 53%.


rosenzweigweb.jpgMARK ROSENZWEIG, Editor in Chief of Chemical Processing, can be e-mailed at mrosenzweig@putman.net.

More from this perspective...

Title

Marshalltown Really Builds Upon a Legacy

State-of-the-art valve testing facility occupies site of historic factory

06/03/2010

Obama Tackles Safety Board Vacancies

President nominates new chair and member for Chemical Safety Board.

04/06/2010

Sustainability Proves Its Worth

Study points to considerable cash flow benefits from better performance.

03/15/2010

U.S. Lead in Science and Engineering Erodes

Biennial report points to gains particularly by Asian countries.

02/15/2010

We Need Another A.C. Gilbert

Toy maker knew how to interest children in science and engineering.

01/06/2010

Grasp All the Lessons of Bhopal

Industry still hasn't adequately addressed one factor behind the disaster.

11/24/2009

Industry Safety Initiative Deserves Applause

The American Chemistry Council is moving proactively to influence legislation.

09/14/2009

Call It "Dereliction of Duty"

Chemical companies too often don't exercise enough care when deactivating units.

08/27/2009

Make the Most of Your Summer Reading

Two new books provide important insights and guidance about plant safety.

07/16/2009

Getting the Right Total Isn’t Easy

Our vendor rankings account for numerous current and retired brands.

06/29/2009

Succession Planning: Avoid a Dumb Move

Stinting on capturing the expertise of departing employees is a false economy.

05/27/2009

Have You Heard the One about the Chemical Engineer?

There’s really nothing funny about our image as technocrats.

04/23/2009

Rosenzweig's Ramblings January 2009 : How Should Industry Tackle Threats?

New report promotes inherently safer technology for hazardous facilities.

04/09/2009

Rosenzweig's Ramblings February 2009: Convince A Child To Explore Engineering

American kids need more awareness of engineering careers -- and a better education.

04/09/2009

Rosenzweig's Ramblings March 2009: Spend Slack Time Smartly

You finally may have a chance to focus on a variety of worthwhile projects.

04/09/2009

Chemical Engineers Crow

New Web site celebrates the profession's past and prospective achievements

03/18/2009

Spend Slack Time Smartly

You finally may have a chance to focus on a variety of worthwhile projects.

03/02/2009

Give An Enduring Gift | Rosenzweig's Ramblings December 2008

Donating time and expertise can transform the lives of people in the developing world.

02/24/2009

Convince A Child to Explore Engineering

American kids need more awareness of engineering careers — and a better education.

01/21/2009

How Should Industry Tackle Threats?

New report promotes inherently safer technology for hazardous facilities.

12/22/2008