Perspectives: Field Notes

Don’t Flub Front-End Loading

Ignoring the early phases of front-end loading can imperil project success

By Dirk Willard, Contributing Editor

An operating company asked an engineering firm to develop a thermal oxidizer/scrubber system with triple redundancy. The firm reported back that the system would cost about $30 million. “That’s way too expensive,” the company responded. Finally, after three attempts, the company thanked the firm for its time, paid for the design, and said it had $10 million in mind. Now, here’s a company sorely in need of better front-end loading (FEL). This project was probably dead on arrival, or should have been in FEL-1 or, perhaps, FEL-0. Let’s talk about FEL-0. (By the way, an executive at the company told me there’s no such thing as FEL-0.)

Read more

More from this perspective...

Title

Weak Oversight Can Doom a Project

Don't timidly accept whatever a contractor proposes.

11/02/2010

Do Your Level Best

Level control with dP transmitters appears simple but really isn't.

11/29/2010

Stop Loops Driving You Round the Bend

Practical pointers trump educators' edicts for real-world process control.

01/12/2011

Heat Exchangers -- Keep Out of Hot Water

Some simple steps can ease heat exchanger commissioning.

02/03/2011

Know Your Rights

Intellectual property agreements can pose significant concerns.

03/03/2011

Don't Zone Out On Area Classifications

Electrical ratings must start with analysis of chemicals present.

04/06/2011

Don't Push the Envelope

Take a sensible approach to avoid ignition dangers.

05/05/2011

Survey the Sources of Electrical Risks

A walk-down helps determine the need for purged electrical boxes.

06/14/2011

Succeed at Process Troubleshooting

Take advantage of five easy techniques to find the root cause of problems.

08/08/2011

Work On Workarounds

Treat them as problems that can compromise plant safety.

08/31/2011

Silence Kills

Foster an atmosphere where workers speak up about concerns.

09/26/2011

Don't Devalue Isometrics

They sometimes can tell you a lot more than P&IDs

10/19/2011

Savor Construction Sites

But make sure the excitement remains enjoyable.

11/17/2011

Make Your Drawings Match Your Process

Outdated P&IDs can lead to tragedy

12/21/2011

Watch Out for Cross-Contamination

Commissioning can pose risks unless you plan carefully.

01/26/2012

Properly Tackle Fluid Flow Problems

This requires far more than modeling software.

02/22/2012

Look at the Big Picture

Ensure that dealing with a safety problem doesn't cause a second risk.

03/22/2012

Don't Add Pressure to Relief Valve Surveys

Consider the time and cost necessary to do a proper analysis.

04/18/2012

Test the Mettle of FRP Tanks

Commissioning and operating such vessels demands special care.

05/09/2012

Fight Over-Confidence

Most people aren’t as good as they think at their jobs.

06/21/2012