Perspectives: Field Notes

Get Your Head Around Shutoff Head

Specifying control valves that may need to provide tight cutoff requires care

By Dirk Willard, Contributing Editor

A data sheet for a reactor flow-control valve called for a “shutoff head.” Given that this control valve handled ethylene oxide (EO), a highly volatile and reactive compound, the requirement gave me pause. Addressing it involved more than defining the pump deadhead pressure. Here’re some thoughts to consider.

First, it’s important to understand that a control valve isn’t a shutoff valve. A control valve must provide precise adjustments to flow. Crunching down on the plug to block flow can cause damage. The actuator and linkage of a control valve aren’t designed for tight shutoff; a shutoff valve’s actuator is. If you want to prevent leakage, install a shutoff valve.

Unfortunately, no standards define control-valve shutoff head. A few describe leakage through the body of a valve; this leakage is categorized poorly as Class I-VI in ANSI/FCI 70-2, “Control Valve Seat Leakage.” Valves also leak from their stems. For stem leakage, refer to ISO-15848, “Industrial Valves — Measurement, Test and Qualification Procedures for Emissions – Part 1...” This specification is best because it recommends helium as the test medium. API-622, “Type Testing of Process Valve Packing for Fugitive Emissions,” also describes stem leakage but for methane.

However, we’re concerned about defining the shutoff head for a control valve specification, not leakage. For this, understanding the limits of valve body type is important. Obviously, butterfly valves won’t provide tight shutoff — although I have seen them used where leaking is acceptable, such as where thermal expansion is allowed. Be aware that thermal expansion could cause the valve seat to stretch or dislodge. In this case, the valve itself limits the shutoff head. Butterfly valves are available with shutoff heads of 175 psi and up, but, in practical terms, the limit is more like 50 psi or less. Diaphragm and other soft-seat valves have the same problem. Gate valves, with their exposed seats and metal-on-metal sealing surfaces, are a bad choice. Globe valves, while often most effective for control, are the worst option. Ball and plug valves probably offer the best choice for shutoff.

Lack of mechanical strength is a common problem with soft seats but less of an issue with hard, metal-on-metal seats. Soft seats are best for sealing against streams containing solids, such as slurries. Hard surfaces, polished smooth, work best at high temperatures, above 250°F, where polymers begin to break down or flow; solids quickly ruin polished surfaces. Fluoropolymers can extend the range of soft seats to 350°F. However, hard plastics retain memory and can be scratched just like metal; memory retention gets worse above 200°F. Partially-fluorinated polymers generally outperform polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) in fabricated liners but PTFE serves well as sheets. Ceramics offer a useful alternative to metal in erosive environments but not without sacrificing tight shutoff.

Enough about the peripherals, let’s get down to specifications. Several scenarios can define shutoff head: 1) flow provided by a mover, e.g., a pump or compressor; 2) pressure isolation; 3) temperature control; and 4) safety, i.e., prevention of a chemical reaction. In the first case, use the deadhead pressure of the mover. (Deadhead is the extreme left corner on a pump curve.) For a pump, pick the deadhead for the largest impeller possible. For temperature control, use the regulator steam pressure — unless a significant risk is present and the steam is stepped down, in which case use the original pressure. Safety is a tricky subject.

If a chemical such as EO is involved, safety trumps a pump curve. EO leaking past the isolation valves to the reactor could lead to a release or worse. In this situation, as in the others requiring a tradeoff between control and isolation, don’t rely on a control valve for shutoff: put automatic valves upstream and downstream of the control valve for isolation. Install pressure switches and pressure transmitters to monitor thermal expansion and use thermal relief valves to blow expanding liquids back to storage. Both switches and transmitters are valuable because transmitters are limited to <100-ms response time and switches don’t trend.

Lastly, let’s look at actuators. If a control valve is to function as a reliable shutoff valve, a positioner is an absolute necessity. Ideally, use one with a 0–100% position indicator. Specify an open-and-closed position indicator for all automatic valves used for shutoff. Take care in selecting the actuator air pressure and supply; evaluate the pressure reliability before selection; plan for 1 scfm of air per control valve or automatic valve that’s 6 in. or less in size.


dirk.jpgDIRK WILLARD is a Chemical Processing contributing editor. He recently won recognition for his Field Notes column from the ASBPE. Chemical Processing is proud to have him on board. You can e-mail him at dwillard@putman.net

More from this perspective...

Title

Learn Office Politics

Improving your political savvy can help you survive.

01/07/2010

Don’t let a start-up finish you off

Senior Editor Dirk Willard spent years as a "start-up" engineer. He advises that proper planning is crucial for achieving a happy ending.

01/24/2006

A methodical approach to construction and commissioning

A start-up is only as easy as the preceding steps: construction and commissioning, says Senior Editor Dirk Willard in his monthly column.

02/10/2006

Check out before you start up

In his monthly Field Notes column, Senior Editor Dirk Willard reveals that regardless of the preparation, check-out tests always bring out some surprises.

02/28/2006

Don’t Be the Hub of a Wheel

Successful ‘green-field’ site start-ups depend on developing a team, says Senior Editor Dirk Willard.

08/17/2006

Twisting the dragon's tail

Complacency is a problem when violating safety rules has no repercussions.

08/18/2006

Remember the old reliable orifice plate

The cost-effective dP flow meter is ideal for utility surveys, Senior Editor Dirk Willard says in this month's Chemical Processing Field Notes column.

09/11/2006

Choosing the right contract

A contract can be a stone in your shoe. Knowing which type of contract to choose can make your job easier. Chemical Processing's Senior Editor Dirk Willard provides tips on various types of contracts.

09/20/2006

Work to build coalitions with difficult teams

Managing feuds is the first step toward a successful project, according to Senior Editor Dirk Willard in his monthly installment of Chemical Processing's Field Notes column.

10/24/2006

Making Your Process Operator-Proof

Senior Editor Dirk Willard discusses Shigeo Shingo's take on mistake-proofing, or Poke Yoke, if you speak Japanese. The practice suggests the following devices: eliminate — redesign, facilitate — guide, mitigate — lessen the damage caused by the error, or flag — identify the error.

12/05/2006

Solve the real problem

Sometimes solving a problem causes more harm than good

08/27/2008

Know when to leave a sinking ship

The unspoken truth about projects is that they all come to an end, according to Dirk Willard in this month's Field Notes column. The key, he says, is knowing when to leave.

01/03/2007

Rely on an Ombudsman for a Smoother Project

Working with someone who speaks the operator’s language will avoid problems, according to Dirk Willard, in this month's Field Notes column.

02/12/2007

Pressure tests can spur successful start-up

Push it: if it breaks it probably needed to be replaced, says Dirk Williard, in this month's Field Notes column. Doing so can help improve your processes.

03/01/2007

Choose the right fluid for your pressure test

Compressed gas often makes the most sense for checking a process, according to Senior Editor Dirk Willard, in this month's Field Notes column.

04/12/2007

Strike the Right Balance

Make the walk-through your first line of defense, advises Dirk Willard in this month's Field Notes column.

04/30/2007

Electives can contribute significantly to professional growth

Taking electives can help you broaden your skills, says Dirk Willard, in this month's Field Notes installment.

07/24/2007

Don’t get zapped by spark testing

Understand the intricacies of checking for defects in a liner, advises Dirk Willard, contributing editor, in this month's Field Notes column.

08/28/2007

Learning foreign languages can make your job easier

Don’t build walls, by ignoring foreign languages, says Contributing Editor Dirk Willard, in this month's Field Notes column. Learning foreign languages can make your job easier.

10/04/2007

Take a studied approach to plant studies

Carefully address the challenges of managing and directing specialized teams

03/13/2008