In general, what are the pros and cons of a parallel shaft, helical gear design gear reducer (e.g. Chemineer MR or Lightnin Series 98) versus a right angle, helical/spiral bevel design (e.g. Chemineer HT or Lightnin Series 70)? My application is for a top-entering mixer in a vertical batch reactor mixing low to medium viscosity liquids with a maximum output speed of 68 RPM. The reactor is fully baffled with dished heads.
Topic: What are the advantages/disadvantages of a parallel-shaft vs. right-angle gear drive?20 August 2012
Have an insight or suggestion?
Login or register to post a comment.
Dave Dickey Forum Moderator 300 Posts
Re: What are the advantages/disadvantages of a parallel-shaft vs. right-angle gear drive?20 August 2012 at 3:52pmThe advantages/disadvantages of a parallel-shaft vs. right-angle gear drive are more practical than technical.
The parallel-shaft drive is taller than the right-angle drive. Therefore, the parallel-shaft drive will require more headroom above the mixed tank. The right-angle drive, being shorter will fit with a lower ceiling or roof height.
The right-angle drive covers more of the top of the tank, surrounding the mixer. It the tank had many pipes and sensors in multiple nozzles on the top of the tank, the more vertical parallel-shaft drive may be better.
On the technical side, the parallel-shaft drive may be less expensive for the same amount of torque because helical gears are typically less expensive than spiral-bevel gears (for a right-angle drive). The output shaft speed should be possible with double reduction in either parallel-shaft or right-angle drives. Both types of gears are efficient, so you have little advantage or disadvantage between those choices. Right-angle, worm-gear drives are typically less efficient than the other two types of drives, but not with any problems for the output speed.
If you are dealing with high pressure in a closed tank, bearing design becomes more important, but most pressures can be handled with either drive type.
The right answer probably gets back to the question of space and access to the mixer, not the gear drive features.
The answers by this expert are based on the best available interpretation of the information provided. The consequences of the application of this information are the responsibility of the user. If clarification is needed, please submit a further question.