Optimize Batch Distillation

Proper design depends upon an understanding of key relationships.

By John E. Edwards, P & I Design

Share Print Related RSS
Page 3 of 5 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 View on one page

The reflux ratio

R = L/D (6)

relates to the slope of the operating line,m, via:

m = L/V = R/(R+ 1) (7)

The overall mass balance at the top of the column is:

D/V= 1/(R+ 1) (8)

The mass balance demonstrates that the top composition is established by the D/V ratio, which depends upon the reflux ratio. If the D/V ratio is high, separation will be low and withdrawal of distillate must be stopped while a relatively high value of the mvc mole fraction, XD, remains, i.e., light ends recovery will be poor. If theD/Vratio is reduced to enhance recovery, the distillation may consume an uneconomic amount of time and energy.

A mass balance on the mvc yields the following relationship, known as the Rayleigh equation:

(dS)XC = d(SXS) (9)

ln (S0/S1) = (10)

The overall mass balance for the system gives:

S0 – S1 = C(11)

A mass balance on the mvc yields:

S0XS0 – S1XS1 = CXC (12)

and by transposing:

C/S0 = (XS0 – XS1)/(XC – XS1)(13)

S1 = S0(XS0 – XC)/(XS1 – XC) (14)

The Fenske equation uses a separation factor, F, to establish the minimum number of theoretical stages, NMIN, required at total reflux to achieve a specified separation of a binary mixture with near-ideal behavior:

NMIN ln α = ln F(15)

F = [XD/(1 – XD)][(1 – XS)/XS] (16)

where XD and XS are the mole fractions of the mvc in the distillate and still compositions, respectively, and α is the relative volatility of the two components.

If a given column can achieve the required separation at total reflux, the next step is to determine the minimum reflux ratio, Rmin, using Underwood’s equation for a binary system:

Rmin = [1/(α - 1)][(XD/XS) – α(1 – XD)/(1 – XS)](17)

When the distillate must contain the mvc at high purity, i.e., XD >0.995 mole fraction, Eq. 17 simplifies to:

Rmin = 1/(α - 1)XS(18)

For a high separation factor, a minimum relative volatility of 1.5 is considered reasonable, thus setting a top limit of Rmin at 2/XS. Batch distillations should start with Rmin equal to that required for a continuous split; Rmin increases as the amount of the mvc in the still decreases.

The total reboiler heat input to reduce the reactor contents from S0 to S1 moles for a variable top composition, achieved by setting a fixed reflux ratio, is:

Q = λ(S0 – S1)(R + 1) (19)

where λ is the latent heat of vaporization.

The reboiler heat input for a fixed top composition, achieved by varying the reflux ratio to maintain a fixed top temperature at constant pressure, is:

Q = λ(S0 – S1) (20)

Both relationships indicate that the reflux ratio must be kept to a minimum, subject to satisfying the requirements for the desired separation specification, to minimize the heat input.

The boil-up rate,V, without reflux is:

V = Q/λ (21)

At total reflux, the reboiler heat duty is:

Q = V(λ + Ht (22)

where H is the liquid specific heat andtsub is condenser subcool in °C.

The batch time, θbatch, at constant reflux ratio is given by:

θbatch = [(R +1)/V](S0 – S1) = λ/V (23)


The boil-up rate achievable with stirred jacketed reactors depends upon many factors, including operational temperature difference, jacket heating media and heat transfer considerations [2, 6].

The fundamental equation for heat transfer is:

Q = UAΔtmean = fjHj(t2 – t1)(24)

where Q is the still heat duty, U is the overall heat transfer coefficient, A is the heat transfer area, Δtmean is the mean temperature difference, fj is jacket fluid flow and Hj is jacket fluid specific heat.

Δtmeanwith a still bottoms temperature tbotand jacket-fluid inlet and outlet temperatures t1 and t2 is approximated by:

Δtmean = (t2 – t1)/2 – tbot(25)

The overall heat transfer coefficient is the sum of the individual resistances, i.e.:

1/U = 1/hi + 1/hfi + 1/(kw/x) + 1/ho + 1/hfo (26)

where hi is the inside film coefficient, hfi is the inside fouling coefficient, kw is the thermal conductivity of the still wall, x is the vessel wall thickness, ho is the outside film coefficient and hfo is the outside fouling coefficient.

Page 3 of 5 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 View on one page
Share Print Reprints Permissions

What are your comments?

Join the discussion today. Login Here.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments