Anti-Corrosion Coatings: Novel Approach to Offshore Manufacturing Pays Off

Coating manufacturer succeeds by thinking differently about project

By David Ciglar, Rust Bullet

2 of 3 1 | 2 | 3 View on one page

The first step is to recognize the variables that matter most — and ignore preconceptions that will steer you in the wrong direction. For example, when looking for a contract manufacturer, conventional wisdom tells us to find a company with deep experience making products just like ours. The company should be well equipped to produce the volume we're looking for, at the right price, on schedule.

This is the classic turnkey approach to contract manufacturing. It's based on a narrow definition of what "manufacturing" really means — as though manufacturing can exist in a vacuum, disconnected from other vital business functions. Following this approach can lead to a rigid, uncreative business relationship that confines the contract manufacturer to a silo, fulfilling orders but insulated from other functions such as product innovation, marketing and sales.

We wanted a more integrated and collaborative relationship that would generate more value. So, instead of looking for a "canned" manufacturing solution in which production capacity and the usual profit/loss line items are paramount, we put trust and integrity at the top of our list of priorities.

Most companies use a firewall of secrecy to protect themselves against the risk that a contractor may reveal confidential information to a competitor. We believe that if you choose a partner that clearly shares your values and demonstrates a strong sense of honesty and integrity, you safely can reveal more about your product and your understanding of the market. There always will be an element of risk but you may receive a much bigger return on your investment than with the usual, guarded contract manufacturing relationship.

In our case, we already knew our future manufacturing partner pretty well. PT National Energy Solutions (PT/NES) of Jakarta, Indonesia, had been one of Rust Bullet's international distributors for a year when the company proposed manufacturing our product in Indonesia. Like Rust Bullet, PT/NES is a family-owned company that's successful, diversified and growing quickly. It also values honesty, trust and integrity as highly as we do.

Moreover, as a distributor, PT/NES had gained a firsthand understanding of our buyers and how they use our products.

With our partner selected, the next task was to create a manufacturing environment perfectly suited to the Rust Bullet process. We agreed the best solution was to construct a new plant rather than retrofit a plant originally designed for another process. The climate in Jakarta is inhospitable to moisture-cured resin — with daytime temperatures over 90°F and humidity over 80%. So this was our primary focus. In the new plant, all processing functions occur within a climate-controlled core, where the temperature hovers at 60°F and the humidity never exceeds 50%.

Our next task was to replicate our domestic manufacturing process in the new plant. To accomplish this, we specified the exact same mixing equipment and controls that we'd tested and optimized in the U.S.; these were built by our equipment partner, Charles Ross & Son Company (another family-owned firm with global operations -- see sidebar at end of this article). Ross's West Coast technical expert Rick O'Boyle led us through the specification process for the scaled-up mixing equipment, ancillaries and controls needed. The equipment then was constructed in one of Ross's plants in China and delivered to the new plant in Jakarta. This strategy enabled us to capture all the benefits of equipment specified, engineered, tested and proven to produce the quality product for which Rust Bullet is known, as well as the cost-efficiency of having it built and shipped locally in Asia.

The new state-of-the-art production facility, which is ISO 9001:2008 certified, started up in June 2012 (Figure 2); chemists in its analytical laboratory focus equally on quality assurance, product development and process improvement.

The conventional wisdom about offshore manufacturing is that as the complexity of a process increases, the risk of failure rises just as fast. According to this reasoning, low-wage countries are most suited to providing labor for simple operations. With more-demanding processes, quality problems might drain away the savings going offshore initially promised.

Our experience demonstrates how outdated this "wisdom" really is. The Rust Bullet product is a high performance coating. The process to create it is precise and extremely demanding, allowing virtually no room for error. Yet, we found that with the right equipment and a manufacturing partner that invests in its production team and applies automation intelligently, we can generate end-product that's always on specification. (Every batch is tested in the plant's onsite laboratory.)

The best way to invest in people is to provide comprehensive training. Ross's technical director Ken Langhorn travelled from the company's Hauppauge, N.Y., test and development center to Jakarta and led our production team through a concentrated program of startup, equipment training and process optimization. From equipment operators to managers, the whole staff was trained and cross-trained. Process parameters were tested and tweaked until the product coming off the line was exactly on specification. [See the sidebar for his pointers on process transfer.]

We video-recorded every presentation and training session he conducted. This enables us to leverage our original program to train new employees as we grow. We also replay the training sessions every six months to refresh the skills of veteran employees on the plant floor.

Old ideas about offshore manufacturing are changing fast. Mainstream media love to report that companies focused on cost now are moving manufacturing operations from China to more-affordable labor-rich countries. Meanwhile, high-brow academic and financial media are warning that manufacturing mustn't be isolated from product innovation. In their view, this is why some offshore manufacturing is starting to move back to the U.S. (so-called reshoring), where innovation supposedly is located. Others still insist that only simple processes belong in offshore plants.

2 of 3 1 | 2 | 3 View on one page
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments