Compressed Air Systems: The Secret is in the Pipe

There’s no such thing as too large a compressed air line.  A common error in compressed air systems is line sizes too small for the desired air flow.

By Hank van Ormer, Don van Ormer and Scott van Ormer

3 of 3 1 | 2 | 3 > View on one page

Pressure drop is proportional to the square of the velocity. Any high-volume, intermittent demand produces dramatic pressure drop during peak periods. Ignoring this fact affects every process connected to the header. For more detail, see “The compressed air receiver: The endless question,” page 49, Plant Services, May 1997 and Appendix 1, Tables and Outline from DOE/CAC Air Master Training Manual. For a given size pipe:

  • At constant pressure, the greater the flow, the greater the loss per foot of pipe.
  • At constant flow rate, the lower the inlet pressure, the greater the loss per foot of pipe.
  • At any condition, smooth-bore pipe (copper, stainless steel) exhibits lower friction losses.

Air velocity
The most overlooked idea in piping layout and design is air velocity. Excessive velocity can be a root cause of backpressure, erratic control signals, turbulence and turbulence-driven pressure drop.

The British Compressed Air Society suggests that a velocity of 20 fps or less prevents carrying moisture and debris past drain legs and into controls. A velocity greater than 30 fps is sufficient to transport any water and debris in the air stream. Thus, the recommended design pipeline velocity for interconnecting piping and main headers is 20 fps or less, and never to exceed 30 fps. Field testing reveals that, under these conditions, air stream turbulence is generally negligible. Line drops, feed lines or branch lines less than 50 ft. long work well at a velocity of 30 fps, but velocity here should not exceed 50 fps.

Crunching numbers
First, look at the velocity at maximum anticipated flow conditions using the following equation:

V = 3.056 * Q/D[+]2[+] (Eqn 1)

Where V = air velocity (in ft/sec)
Q = volumetric flow rate (in cfm)
D = conduit inside diameter (in inches)

Although this method of determining the minimum pipe size on the basis of air velocity is easy, you also must consider that the compressed air volume is expressed in cubic feet per minute of free air, which is the air volume at ambient atmospheric conditions, not the compressed volume.

To adjust the inlet air volumetric flow rate to actual pipeline conditions, you’ll need to divide the volume of free air by the compression ratio using the following equation:

CR = (P+P[-]a[-])/P[-]a[-] (Eqn 2)

Where P = line pressure (in psig)
P[-]a[-] = average atmospheric pressure at your elevation (in psi)

Table 1 shows the compression ratio as a function of gauge pressure for a location at sea level, where the atmospheric pressure is 14.7 psi. At higher elevations, the average atmospheric pressure drops and the compression ratio rises. For example, Flagstaff, Ariz., at a 7,000-ft. elevation, has an average atmospheric pressure of about 11 psi. At 100 psig, the compression ratio is equal to 10 (i.e. 111/11).

To determine the pipeline velocity at conditions, merely divide the velocity given in Equation 1 by the compression ratio given in Equation 2. After selecting the minimum pipe size on the basis of velocity, check any long runs for excessive pressure drop using an appropriate drop chart. For example, a velocity of 25 fps in black iron pipe represents about 0.25 psi loss per 100 ft. of run. Although this is a little above the recommended minimum of 20 fps and, depending on the layout, would probably be acceptable from a turbulence standpoint, a high total frictional loss may dictate using a larger pipe.

This might seem to be somewhat complicated at first, but it’s the most accurate way to avoid problems in sizing compressed air piping. Once you get the hang of it, it’s easy to use.

After carefully selecting a conduit size that eliminates unnecessary loss, be sure to pay the same attention to downstream items, such as quick disconnects, regulators, filters, controls, fittings, number of drops from a given header and number of connections per header, so as not to offset the gains made with the pipe. Good piping performance is not an accident -– it takes planning.

Hank van Ormer, Don van Ormer and Scott van Ormer are owners of AirPower USA, Pickerington, Ohio. Contact them at HankvanOrmer@aol.com and (740) 862-4112.

3 of 3 1 | 2 | 3 > View on one page

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments. Please comply with our Community rules.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

  • Nice blog..!!

    Reply

  • < According to the charts, a short run of small-bore pipe exhibits a low total frictional pressure drop, but the high velocity causes an extremely large, turbulence-driven pressure drop >

    I'm not understanding what is being said/implied here. If I use Crane as an example, 50 cfm free air through a 1/2" sch 40" pipe has a pressure drop of 8.49 psi per 100 feet piping, this pressure drop is actually low?

    Reply

  • Using the similarity of air pressure to voltage, flow rate to current, and pipe friction loss to wire resistance, we should maybe consider borrowing an electrical practice.

    In electrical design, wire sizes are selected to limit voltage drop in the distribution room to 2%, and to limit voltage drop from the electric room to the farthest point to 3%.

    Using this logic for a 100 PSI compressor, the piping in the compressor room should be selected for a 2 PSI drop to the compressor room wall, and the piping in the plant is size for a 3 psi drop to the farthest point of use.

    Instead of complaining about the cost of "oversized" pipe, we should point out the energy saved for the life of the plant's operation.

    Reply

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments